Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Fix your mindset before you spend a dollar: For a small operator, marketing spend comes straight out of your own paycheck — which is why some owners stay timid even when a spreadsheet shows exactly what came back. Drop the demand for instant predictability, too: put-in-X-get-out-Y only exists after years of testing, and what worked in Florida won’t copy-paste to California. If you expect ads to be profitable on day one, get that idea out of your head now.
Split a $3k budget roughly 70/30, guests to owners: The hosts’ rule of thumb at $3,000 a month: about 70 percent to guest marketing, 30 percent to homeowner acquisition. The philosophy underneath is high intent and high ROI — spend at the bottom of the funnel first, on the people already looking for you, before you buy awareness.
Build Google Ads in layers, starting with your own property names: Roughly $1,000 of the guest budget goes to Google Ads, built from the most specific searches upward — and nowadays often as Performance Max rather than classic search campaigns.
- Layer one: your property, cabin, and brand names
- Layer two: long-tail terms like ’North Myrtle Beach pet friendly vacation homes’
- Layer three: broad destination searches — only after the first two are optimized
Expect 5-to-6x ROAS at first, then push toward 10x: Five or six to one is roughly breakeven for most management companies, so treat it as the floor. Within 90 to 120 days the target is closer to eight or ten to one — $1,000 in spend producing $8,000 to $10,000 in gross booking revenue, counting rent and fees but never taxes. Know your own margins before deciding what’s acceptable.
Cover email, social, and local SEO with scrappy versions: One newsletter a month is the bare minimum, plus a welcome series for new subscribers — budget for the email platform and a freelancer to run it. Social is you, a gimbal, and an iPhone; a professional video shoot isn’t happening at this level. Round it out with reviews, Google Business Profile work, the template website your PMS came with, and a small retargeting budget.
Skip paid ads for owners — go dream-100 direct mail and networking: The one non-negotiable is a landing page targeting what owners actually search: property management in your area, STR regulations. Then get hyper-targeted — 100 high-value mail pieces to your dream 50 to 100 properties beat 1,000 generic postcards. The rest is coffees with realtors and chamber events, and always answer what the realtor gets from the referral. It’s wine-and-dine B2B, not a one-call close.
Don’t blow this budget on a full-time hire: A $100,000 generalist can’t be an expert in SEO, PPC, email, and content — and the salary consumes the whole budget, leaving nothing for the tools and freelancers that would make them effective. Use specialists in small doses, or split an existing employee’s week, like a reservationist doing marketing three days. Count fully loaded costs: payroll taxes, software subscriptions, all of it.
Nobody hires the fifth-best manager in town: If you’re genuinely the fifth-best manager in your market, it’s almost right that you get no leads — nobody’s excited about the ninth-best restaurant either. Do great work and be honest about your size; Conrad’s worst early move was posing as an agency, and owning ’you work directly with me’ is what signed clients. Most managers climb the ladder — condos, then townhomes, then homes — and a luxury home that was easy to sign is easy to lose.
Budget for the trough of disappointment: Marketing rarely works immediately — the trough is measured in months, not weeks, though it shouldn’t run 12. Committing to $3,000 a month really means committing to the cumulative $6,000, $9,000, and $12,000 that follow. Quit in month two and you paid for the lessons but left before the results.
What We Cover In This Episode
Part one of Conrad and Paul’s marketing budget series: how they’d spend $3,000 a month for a vacation rental company — the 70/30 guest-owner split, layered Google Ads, realistic ROAS targets, and dream-100 owner outreach — plus the mindset and hiring traps that sink small budgets.
