Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Being local only counts if someone is actually on the ground: Everyone in this industry says we’re local – for plenty of companies it’s just the address. Real local marketing means someone on-site filming real video, knowing which events actually move the needle versus which only matter to the community, and posting in real time. That authenticity is exactly what gets harder to fake as AI floods the feed.
Skip the unicorn hire and split creation from scheduling: A $50-70K full-time social media manager is rarely an ROI-positive hire, and the person who’s genuinely great at social, ads, email, and SEO costs multiple six figures. Cross-train a local staffer to film properties on their phone, drop footage in a shared folder, and let an editor anywhere in the world cut and schedule it. Creation must be local; distribution doesn’t.
Hire for fingerprints, not platform name-dropping: Candidates who lead with knowing Facebook and Instagram are offering table stakes. Ask what they’ve actually run themselves – even a fraternity account with proof counts – or have them pick an account they admire and explain exactly how they’d recreate what works. Strategy and execution are the value; scheduling posts is blocking and tackling.
Facebook groups are the most underrated local channel: Clients who’ve gotten dialed into local Facebook groups prove it works: show up regularly, add value, watch for the signal topics, and become the person who gets tagged whenever someone asks about vacation rentals. It’s not a big content plan – it’s grocery-store-line minutes invested consistently.
Social media can’t polish a mediocre business: Anyone could post Apple’s next ten launches and rack up millions of views – that’s decades of brand equity, not posting skill. If your properties, photos, and videos aren’t interesting, no manager can shine them up. The social-first companies you envy designed photographable properties from day one and built the whole business around it.
Never pass off AI imagery as the real place: Retouching a real photo or adding AI text graphics is fine – that’s the fashion-shoot cleanup. Generating fake sunsets, fireplaces, or beach proximity for a property people will physically visit guarantees a disappointment gap and one-star reviews, and the LLMs can detect and tag AI images anyway. A no-AI, this-is-our-actual-view stance may soon be a selling point.
A focused 5,000-follower account beats a 100,000-follower mashup: Roll-up brands posting twelve destinations from one account lose everyone – the Park City follower doesn’t care about your Cape Cod post. An account where every follower chose it for one destination will crush the big generic one on reach and growth. Follower count is a vanity metric; interest match is what compounds.
You’re in the acquisition business, whether you like it or not: This business needs a new guest every two to four days from now until the business is dead. If nobody in your company lives and breathes cheaper bookings and more signed homeowners, you’ll grow at two or three homes a year – or not at all. Operators who are truly anti-marketing should consider long-term rentals instead.
Offshore the analysis, but never skip the local context: Revenue management doesn’t require living in the market – one Florida client’s revenue team sits in Europe and performs great. But a remote analyst who won’t interrogate the local calendar will sell out the biennial festival at $300 a night that locals know commands $1,000. Walk through last year’s peaks before pricing this year’s.
Start your local content engine for $500: Asked how they’d spend $500 on local content, both hosts land in the same place.
- A gimbal (about $100) and a clip-on mic – your current phone is probably enough camera
- Reps: a team member filming property walkthroughs until they’re actually good at it
- $10-20 boosts pushing organic posts to warm audiences – site visitors and past guests
- Co-created evergreen content with local businesses that already have followings
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul dig into what claiming to be local actually has to mean before it becomes a marketing advantage: who films the content, what you can safely offshore, how to hire for social without chasing unicorns, where AI imagery crosses the line, and how each of them would spend $500 on local content today.
