Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Google’s helpful content update rewarded human-first writing: The biggest search shift of 2022 pushed sites toward content written for people, not algorithms — and the vacation rental industry, which generally produces decent destination content, weathered it better than most verticals. The lasting lesson: treat AI writing tools as a productivity multiplier for a skilled writer, never a copy-paste replacement for one.
Most Google updates never get announced: Google makes over 5,000 changes to search in a year and names only a handful. If your traffic spikes or slides on a random Tuesday, it may be an update nobody blogged about. Diagnose from your own data instead of assuming every swing maps to a named core update.
Perfect attribution is gone — optimize on the signals you keep: The iOS privacy changes knocked over the first domino, and tracking got harder every quarter after. The casualty isn’t big tech — it’s the small operator who just wants to know if their marketing works. Build first-party data like your email list and guest history, and accept directional answers instead of chasing booking-level precision that no longer exists.
Google Ads keeps trading your control for its automation: 2022 retired expanded text ads and made responsive search ads mandatory — and advertisers who embraced RSAs and their built-in multivariate testing generally saw better performance. But the pattern matters more than the feature: Google wants to be the optimizer, and its recommendations serve Google before they serve you. Stay hands-on everywhere the platform still allows it.
Social ads outperform display because they don’t look like ads: Nobody wants a banner interrupting the article they’re reading, which is why Google’s display network struggles against social placements. On TikTok or Instagram, the ad unit looks like the content around it. Google’s targeting data is fine — the placement experience is the gap, and it’s why social kept winning on click-through and engagement.
Vacation rentals are made for short-form video: TikTok crossed a billion users in 2022 with 142% year-over-year growth in active users and ad spend, and the average person was consuming around 100 minutes of video a day. Aspirational property content — tours, views, amenities — is exactly what these platforms reward, and the nicer the property, the better it performs. Dismissing TikTok then looked a lot like dismissing Facebook in 2012, and the camera on your phone was already good enough to start.
Prepare for retargeting to get broader, not sharper: With third-party cookies on the way out, the direction was clear: less precise audience targeting, state-level reach instead of city-level. The durable advice is to own your audience — guest lists, email, first-party signals — rather than renting precision from ad platforms that keep taking it away.
Downturns filter out the tourists: The 2022 shake-out — tech layoffs, the crypto crash, cooling demand — pushed out the get-rich-quick crowd. The self-declared short-term rental experts on LinkedIn one year were pitching drop shipping the next. Consistency in one market, one business, one website compounds into a real advantage precisely because most people won’t sustain it.
Be correct, not consistent: Don’t wait for perfect conditions to enter or invest — operators who learn the business in a slower market look like geniuses in the next run-up. And when the data says a campaign you recommended nine months ago is underperforming, kill it rather than defend it. Blaming the economy or Google’s changes serves you less than staying informed and adjusting.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul recap the changes that shaped vacation rental marketing in 2022 — the helpful content update, the slow death of tracking, Google Ads automation, TikTok’s surge, and early ChatGPT — and pull out the lessons that carried into 2023 and beyond.
