I joined Jamie Lane, Chief Economist at AirDNA, on episode 204 of AirDNA’s STR Data Lab podcast. We talked about when direct bookings actually make financial sense, what a direct booking should really cost you, how to put your brand on your OTA listings without hurting your reviews, and whether AI agents are about to change how guests book vacation rentals.
Watch the full episode
Prefer audio? Listen on AirDNA’s episode page or find STR Data Lab on Apple Podcasts.
Key Takeaways
Measure your size in revenue, not units: At BuildUp, we size clients by gross booking revenue, not listing count. A dedicated direct booking investment starts to pay off at about $1 million a year in gross booking revenue. At AirDNA’s US average of about $56,000 per listing, that’s roughly 18 listings.
Start with a brand guests can find: Before you email anyone or buy ads, you need a brand name, a domain, and a website that show up when a guest searches for you off platform. Next, message past guests (with consent) and run ads on your own brand and property names. The OTAs already run ads on them.
Social works for eye candy, not for condo 127: Visually striking properties do well on Instagram and TikTok. Ordinary inventory usually doesn’t, unless you package it into an offer. One golf stay-and-play package we run brings in 40 to 60 leads a week from Facebook ads.
A direct booking should cost about 10 to 12% all-in: Add up ad spend, staff or agency fees, payment processing, and technology. If the total isn’t clearly lower than what the OTAs charge, the math doesn’t work.
Charge a direct booking fee that funds your marketing: If you give the guest the whole OTA markup back, you have nothing left to market with. The sweet spot I’ve found in testing is a fee of roughly 8%.
Agentic booking is often discussed, rarely done: Most guests use AI at the top of the travel-planning funnel. ChatGPT sends our clients thousands of referrals a month, but guests still finish the booking on Google, the OTAs, and direct websites.
Don’t chase AI before the fundamentals: Don’t block AI crawlers, and keep your site clean and easy to read. But if you’re not running Google Ads or emailing past guests yet, start there.
Full Episode Summary
What we do at BuildUp Bookings (3:22)
Jamie opened with the reply you see all over LinkedIn every time Airbnb, Vrbo, or Booking.com changes a policy: just get more direct bookings. It reminds me of the old Reddit dating advice, “step one, be attractive.” It skips every step in between.
I started BuildUp on July 1, 2016. My background is SEO, and over the years we’ve added paid search, Meta ads, and email and SMS marketing to past guests. The short version: we help vacation rental managers get more direct bookings with search, social, and email marketing.
Whenever I audit a site, I check the same three things. How much search traffic does it get, paid and organic? How much social traffic and reach does it have? How does it reach past guests through email and SMS? Whether you run a condo in Hawaii or a luxury ski chalet in Europe, those three channels are where meaningful direct bookings come from.
When direct bookings actually make financial sense (5:50)
We stopped sizing companies by listing count a while ago, because gross booking revenue tells you much more. My extreme example: we work with a client in the Bahamas who has three listings and does about $2 million a year in rent. An operator like that can easily justify a marketing retainer.
For most managers, the economics start to work at about $1 million in gross booking revenue. Jamie shared that the average US host earns about $56,000 a year per listing, which puts the threshold at roughly 18 listings.
Below that line, it’s still worth setting up basic direct booking infrastructure through your PMS. It catches repeat guests and travelers who go looking for you off platform. I’d expect a small host to get maybe 10 to 20% of bookings direct this way. That helps, but you won’t end up on a beach in Tahiti sipping mai tais because of it.
The numbers get compelling for our clients with 300 to 500 listings that each earn $60,000 to $70,000 a year. Moving their direct share by 5 to 10 points can add something like $100,000 a year in profit. Large managers also hit a supply problem small hosts never see: one platform can’t fill hundreds or thousands of listings that each have different reviews and grades. (We just signed a client with 5,000 units.) At that size, direct bookings are partly just another way to fill the calendar.
This is also why we now tell some smaller prospects on the first call that a marketing retainer doesn’t make sense for them yet.
Step one is a brand guests can find (11:39)
When Jamie asked what comes next after a basic direct booking site, my answer was brand, and honestly it probably belongs first. You need a name, a domain, and a direct booking site that people (and AI agents) can find when they go searching off platform. Vrbo executives used to call that “leakage.” Picking a name that’s easy to search for and find is harder than it sounds.
Step two is acting on it:
- Message past guests, but only if you collected their contact details with their consent and within the platform’s terms of service.
- Run Google Ads on your brand and property names. The OTAs’ automated bidding systems already run ads on unique property names that point to your Airbnb listing, even when your own site ranks first organically. I see it every day with our clients. They’re taking that traffic, so you may as well take it yourself.
I’d expect those basics to bring in your first 10 to 15% of direct bookings.
When social media works, and when it doesn’t (13:40)
Jamie raised the popular idea that Instagram and TikTok are where Gen Z will find travel. My answer: it depends on the property. Social works for places that look interesting enough to stop someone mid-scroll. Think of Ben Wolff’s work marketing unique stays, or Fieldtrip in Joshua Tree, whose ads we run. Fieldtrip’s properties, including the Invisible House, are so striking that people see them and immediately want to stay there.
I live in the Myrtle Beach area, which has about 35,000 condo units within a few miles of where I’m sitting. If you own one of them, you’re unlikely to do well on organic social, however nice the condo is. Honda Civics outsell Ferraris, but the car account that gets the likes posts Ferraris.
Ordinary inventory can still work on social if you sell an offer instead of a unit. One of our clients has about 300 fairly plain golf condos on a course in North Carolina. An ad for the condos alone would get almost nothing. An ad for a stay-and-play package, with unlimited golf, two nights of lodging, and one per-person price, shown to golfers within driving distance, brings in 40 to 60 leads a week on Facebook.
I’d suggest two tests. First, know exactly who your guest is: if it’s everyone, it’s no one. Second, scroll your own Instagram feed for five minutes. If your property wouldn’t stop you between the memes and the NFL highlights, organic social probably isn’t your channel.
What a direct booking should really cost (17:50)
Jamie asked how a manager growing from $1 million to $2 million in revenue should think about the all-in cost of a direct booking, including the things the OTAs normally handle for you, like payment processing, guest verification, and staff.
This is where I see the most variance. The managers who post most about the OTAs on LinkedIn often react emotionally (think of the guest who found a hair in the shower and got a full refund), and they’ll pay more just to get away. The spreadsheet answer is simpler. Add up your agency or staff costs, ad spend, and infrastructure, then divide by your direct booking revenue. The result should be well under 15%, ideally a loaded cost of 10 to 12%. If it isn’t, there’s an argument for doing only the bare minimum. How far above that line you’ll go for more control and less OTA dependence is a personal choice.
The other half of the math is how you price direct stays. I’ve lost count of the managers who raise their OTA rates to cover commission and then give the whole difference back to direct guests. That leaves nothing to market with, and in some cases a direct booking actually costs them money. My recommendation is a direct booking fee of roughly 8%. Guests still pay meaningfully less than on Airbnb, and you have enough margin to fund your marketing. I cover this in detail in Why Direct Booking Fees Boost Revenue & Build Your Marketing Budget.
The other benefits of booking direct (22:55)
Cost and platform dependence are the two big reasons managers want direct bookings, but there are smaller benefits too. I mentioned a presentation by Chris from Direct Booking Tools, who likes that far-out direct bookings for his large Hilton Head homes sit in his own escrow account earning interest. You also keep the guest’s contact details, which matters more under Airbnb’s newer policies. (Airbnb itself earns close to a billion dollars a year from holding guests’ money.)
I’ve also heard from managers who sold their companies, including to Vacasa during its acquisition years, that a steady stream of direct bookings, an email list, and a website were treated as assets that made the business more attractive to buyers.
Jamie brought up Airbnb’s Reserve Now, Pay Later, where Airbnb gave up the float on guest payments because it converted better. The same idea works for managers. Clients of ours who’ve added pay-later or installment options to their checkout have seen a meaningful lift in conversions, even though most PMSs still make it a headache to set up.
Should your brand show up on your OTA listings? (25:50)
Jamie asked whether managers should put their brand on Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com listings to get a billboard effect, given that listings presented as a company tend to be reviewed more harshly than individual hosts.
My example of maximum branding is Sonder. It put its name in listing titles, descriptions, photos, and profile pictures, and got a high share of bookings direct before the company collapsed. For most managers, I recommend a middle path:
- Use a host name that blends person and brand, like “Jamie at [Company].” A North Carolina client we’ve worked with for a long time does this with a profile photo of himself in a branded shirt, though Airbnb may now be able to detect that.
- Leave compliant breadcrumbs, such as a logo on the TV screen, or a line like “This property is managed by [brand] in Blue Ridge, Georgia.”
- Never tell guests to go search for you. They can work it out themselves, and so can AI agents. Always check each platform’s terms of service first.
Jamie added some AirDNA data. Listings run by large professional managers score slightly lower even on location, which should match their neighbors exactly. So the penalty for presenting as a company rather than an individual host is small but real. Airbnb is a rich-get-richer platform, where small differences in reviews change your placement. That’s why some clients have us market new listings harder at launch, to get the first bookings and reviews on the books.
Agentic booking: often discussed, rarely done (31:00)
Next came the hottest topic in the industry: AI agents booking stays on a guest’s behalf, and what that could mean for Airbnb, Expedia, and Booking.com.
My first take: agentic booking is often discussed and rarely actually done. I push back on some claims in the market, like treating an AI crawler visiting your site as the same thing as a person visiting it. I’ve been reading Googlebot log files for more than a decade, and bots crawl every page on the internet that works. A crawl doesn’t mean you’ll get recommended. (Don’t block them either.)
In my view, AI adoption is only now leaving the early adopter phase. Most people still use chat tools for basic tasks like rewording a text. Many of the usage stats being shared come from surveys, which are unreliable, because what people say they do and what they actually do are very different. Ask gym members how often they go, then check their key-card scans.
Where people do use AI is the top of the travel-planning funnel. For example: “We live in Atlanta, we have two kids, where should we go somewhere warm for fall break?” Eventually they switch to Google, Airbnb, or a direct site to choose a place to stay. Across our clients, ChatGPT sends thousands of referrals a month, and nearly all AI referrals come from ChatGPT, even though I’m a Claude user myself. (See our research on how much traffic ChatGPT sends vacation rental websites.)
Different trips also call for different approaches. I’m happy to let an agent book a hotel near the airport in Charlotte, but not an anniversary trip I want to plan down to the last detail. Browsing vacation rentals inside chat tools is still a poor experience, and some solutions ask users to install an MCP server. My mom doesn’t know what an MCP is, and she’s who you’re designing for if agentic booking is supposed to become the default. I’d bet my bank account it won’t be the majority way people book 12 to 18 months from now.
Three ways agentic booking could play out (37:40)
Jamie laid out three scenarios:
- The agent books through OTA pipes, like ChatGPT’s partnership with Expedia. The OTA still gets the booking, much as Google sends traffic to the OTAs today.
- The agent books through an operator’s own feed, like a Marriott integration that knows you’re a Bonvoy member.
- The agent finds the same stay cheaper on a manager’s direct site and books it there for the guest. This is the scenario that worries Wall Street.
I think the first scenario is the most likely in the near term. Power users will figure out the third, but it’s years away from being the majority. Jamie shared a data point that supports this: about 70% of Airbnb’s listings worldwide are exclusive to Airbnb, so for most listings there’s no direct site for an agent to find. Many of those hosts are happy that way, and I’ve stopped trying to convert them.
I’d also warn against reading too much into AI growth stats. A 1,000% year-over-year jump from almost nothing is still a sliver of the pie. And Airbnb has shown it will protect its own interface. It joined Google Vacation Rentals only briefly before pulling out, and Brian Chesky has talked about Airbnb backing out of the early ChatGPT plugins at the last minute, rather than becoming plumbing that could later be swapped for Vrbo.
Long term, I expect a mix of all three, with AI results looking a lot like Google results do today: rich, ad-like cards at the top, with organic results below that still win plenty of clicks. Agents that hunt for a cheaper direct rate remind me of the Honey browser extension finding a product $10 cheaper at Walmart. It’s useful for the shopper, but it doesn’t move Amazon’s stock price.
What managers should do about AI right now (46:00)
Jamie asked how much of a manager’s business could eventually come through AI agents. Honestly, nobody knows. Anyone who says they do is guessing, or may have something to sell. There isn’t even agreement yet on which technical setup makes a site more likely to be recommended.
The one thing everyone agrees on is not to block the agents. If you have the best pizza in Atlanta and lock the front door, customers assume you don’t want their business. Make your site easy for crawlers to read. I’m not convinced you need a separate text-only version of the site to do that.
I expect AI optimization to settle into a checklist, much like my TLCK framework for SEO (technical, link building, content creation, and keyword research) has held up since 2011. Once every site in a market is technically clean, AI tools will separate brands using off-site signals like mentions, links, and reviews. It’s the cousin of SEO. (More in our guide to vacation rental GEO and LLM optimization.)
But do things in order. If you’re not running Google Ads or emailing past guests yet, worrying about agentic bookings for your 50-unit company is a poor use of your time. During the hour we were recording, I’d guess the Google Ads campaigns we run for clients produced around 30 bookings, and I doubt there was a single agentic booking in that time. Get the proven work done first, and don’t get distracted by the woman in the red dress.
Show Notes & Links
- STR Data Lab Episode 204 on AirDNA
- Watch the episode on YouTube
- STR Data Lab on Apple Podcasts
- Jamie Lane on LinkedIn
- Connect with me on LinkedIn
- Why Direct Booking Fees Boost Revenue & Build Your Marketing Budget
- BuildUp Bookings Research: How Much Traffic Does ChatGPT Send Vacation Rental Websites?
- My Book: Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing
- My Course: Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing 101