Podcast: Breaking Down The Reasons WHY Guest Choose Vacation Rentals vs Hotels

Conrad O'Connell
Founder, BuildUp BookingsCo-host, Heads in Beds ShowAuthor, Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing
Conrad has worked in vacation rental marketing for over a decade. He writes from what BuildUp Bookings sees running SEO, paid ads, email and websites for vacation rental managers.
More from Conrad →Last updated: July 25, 2026
Heads In Beds Show — the vacation rental marketing podcast from BuildUp Bookings

Listen to the podcast episode

Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

Key Takeaways

Hotels sell consistency; you sell the property: Marriott has 228 million loyalty members booking on points, perks, and predictability. Blindfold someone in a Hilton versus a Hyatt room and they couldn’t tell you which brand they’re in — and that’s on purpose. Hotels win by commoditizing the room; vacation rentals win by doing the opposite, making the property the differentiator through design, amenities, and architecture. Trying to out-consistency the chains is a losing game.

Match your marketing to your market type: Urban rentals compete head-to-head with hotels for functional travel — low repeat rates, and guests won’t pay much extra for a nicer space. Beach, mountain, and lake markets are a different sport: groups will pay triple or quadruple a hotel rate for a big property that fits everyone under one roof. Even the same three-bedroom performs completely differently at the top of the mountain with a view than at the bottom. Know which demand curve you’re on before you set pricing.

You’re not marketing to one guest, so stop acting like it: Travel purpose changes everything about what a guest values. Conrad traveling solo to a conference needs a bed near the venue; his family traveling with a baby needs a dark room, a noise machine, and a crib. Even vacation rental professionals book hotels for VRMA because it’s the right tool for that trip. One property serves multiple guest types, and your marketing has to connect those puzzle pieces instead of betting on a single audience.

Hotel guests give you exactly one chance: A Best Western guest knows exactly what they’re getting before they walk in — that defined service level is the product. When that guest tries a vacation rental and it’s run poorly, they swear off the whole category and tell Twitter about it. There’s no on-site staff or concierge to recover the stay, so your operations and brand standards have to deliver the first time.

Low barriers to entry cut both ways: Anyone can buy a cabin and list it tomorrow — that’s how Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge, and Broken Bow got flooded when best-places-to-invest lists sent armchair investors piling in after COVID. When the gold rush ends, the average property doing the bare minimum at a premium price stops performing. Hotels can’t oversaturate that fast; a resort takes five-plus years and tens of millions to build. Easy entry means you have to out-operate and out-differentiate the flood.

Don’t build campaigns around use cases nobody searches for: Clients love saying their big homes are perfect for family reunions, church retreats, and girlfriends’ trips — and they are. But almost nobody types ’family reunion vacation rentals in Gulf Shores’ into Google, so pages and ads built on those phrases never match the real booking volume. People search the destination first, then figure out which property fits their group. Capture the demand that exists, then let the website do the matching.

Load your property pages with the details guests filter on: Parking spaces, floor plans, cribs, blackout rooms — guests don’t search for these, but they absolutely book on them. One client had homes that sleep ten with nowhere near ten parking spots, and it caused real problems until he listed the parking count on every property page. Strong photos, video, honest descriptions, and layout details convert the traffic you already have.

Niche properties only work when the niche matches the market: One operator put over a million dollars into three themed cabins in a market where the theme didn’t click. Marketing got the eyeballs and clicks — nobody booked, and the only smart move left was shutting the spend off. A Packers-themed house works in Green Bay and flops in Texas. Bold and specialized can win, but if you guess wrong on what the market wants, no advertising saves the product.

What We Cover In This Episode

Conrad and Paul dig into why travelers actually choose vacation rentals versus hotels — brand loyalty and consistency, market types, travel purpose, and service expectations — and what that means for how you position, price, and market your properties against the hotel down the street.

Show Notes & Links

For Vacation Rental Managers Paying Too Much To The OTAs:

Stop Handing Airbnb 15.5% Of Every Booking

The OTA Escape Plan free direct booking guide for vacation rental managers

The OTA Escape Plan, 2027 Edition: 150 checks across 10 channels, each with why it matters, how to do it and how to know it’s done. Comes with a scorecard workbook and a new section on getting named by ChatGPT and Google’s AI.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Free. No sales call required.