Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Judge ad channels by what the traffic does, not what clicks cost: Everyone repeats that Google Ads are expensive. Wrong frame — the only question is what you get back when you pay: does the traffic convert into bookings? Cost per click is a vanity metric. A $3 click from your ideal guest may be the best traffic your site gets all month; at a 2% conversion rate, $5 a click still profits.
Search is intent, social is interruption — order your spend accordingly: Someone searching vacation rentals in your market has demonstrated intent; a Facebook user has only logged in. It’s the diamond-ring store: interrupt couples on the sidewalk and you’ll sell a few, but the guy who walks in ready to propose buys at ten or twenty times the rate. Any media can work — the question is how well. Run Google Search first, then Facebook and Instagram, and come to display last.
On search, the keyword is the targeting: Someone searching vacation rentals in Destin qualifies themselves by the search — it barely matters whether they’re sitting in Minnesota or Maine. Piling state and audience restrictions on top just shrinks the pool Google can serve ads to, and your cost per click rises the moment you do. Guests come from everywhere; homeowners even more so.
Don’t exclude geographies until the data convicts them: A client swore 90% of his guests came from three states, so that’s all Conrad targeted — until the budget expanded and a state he’d ignored became the third-best converter. Wait for volume: 1,000 clicks from California with zero bookings, cut it. But 1,000 clicks from Texas with eight bookings and 1,000 from Colorado with fourteen? Both stay.
Build Facebook audiences from your own first-party data first: The middle funnel is people who already know you; the top funnel expands from there with uploaded lists and lookalikes. One client seeded a lookalike with only guests who had stayed twice or more — including one who’s stayed 13 times since 2007. Find more of that guy.
- Website and owner-landing-page visitors via the pixel
- Facebook page likers and Instagram followers
- Your email list
- Uploaded guest or owner lists
- Lookalikes built from your best repeat guests
Use video views to reach groups you can’t target directly: You can’t advertise into a local homeowner or realtor Facebook group, and scraping member lists is expensive and unreliable. Post a video the group will see — a holiday card, a company overview — then build a retargeting audience from everyone who watched it. For owner targeting, stacked interests work too: real estate investing plus an Airbnb interest gets you close.
Exclusions are targeting too — but bid down before you cut: Negative keywords and audience exclusions clear out clicks you never wanted, like current homeowners seeing a free-deep-clean offer meant for prospects. But don’t get rigid: sometimes the 18-to-24 click is a kid searching for the parents, so bid down 30% instead of excluding. And past guests commenting ’just booked, staying next week’ on your ad? That usually makes it perform better.
Treat display as brand awareness, not a booking machine: Conrad calls display mystery meat — clients profitably spending five figures a month on search still struggle to make it convert. Measure it by branded-search growth in Search Console, know that custom audiences need 1,000-plus active users just to serve, and police placements so you’re not funding random real-estate and housing sites. One clever play: build an audience from visitors to your competitors’ websites.
You aren’t entitled to the direct booking — you earn it: Your ad runs right beside Airbnb’s for the same search, and the guest already trusts their brand. If your site is slow, your cancellation policy is worse, and the design doesn’t scream trustworthy, targeting won’t save you. Every client getting great direct-booking results has a fast, professional website behind the ads.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul work through ad targeting channel by channel — why search intent beats interruption on Google, how to build Facebook and Instagram audiences from first-party data, when exclusions and bid adjustments beat cutting, and where display fits as a brand play.