Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Don’t rebuild your SEO strategy around an AI search demo: When Conrad and Paul ran real vacation rental queries through Google’s early AI search results, the experience was slow, clunky, and often worse than the classic results sitting underneath it — a C-minus in their grading. Interfaces like this change from one search to the next, so reacting to a beta is wasted energy. Watch, test, and hold your strategy until real patterns emerge from actual traveler behavior.
Search your own brand and see what travelers actually hit: Branded searches for well-known management companies returned social media pages and directory listings with no clean path to the official website — a loop of two, three, four clicks before a guest lands where they intended. That’s the kind of friction you only catch by running your own brand through new search experiences regularly. If travelers can’t get from your name to your site in one click, every other marketing dollar works harder than it should.
AI search leaned local — reviews carried the results: The AI summaries were built largely from Google Business Profile data and consistently favored local companies with strong reviews over the big platforms, stacked roughly best-rated first. Your business listing — address, listing count, about-page details, and review base — became the raw material for the answer. Keeping that profile complete and your reviews healthy is cheap insurance no matter what the results page looks like next.
The OTAs weren’t winning either: Searches for Airbnb rarely routed to Airbnb — results pointed to HomeToGo, Vacasa, TripAdvisor, even Expedia instead. The assumption that AI search would simply hand the industry to the biggest platforms didn’t hold up in practice. If anything, the early results favored local operators, which should temper the doom scenarios for direct booking sites.
Speed and task completion still decide search: Google spent decades shaving tenths of a second off results, then shipped AI summaries that took three to five seconds to generate. A traveler hunting for a pet-friendly cabin doesn’t want prose — they want properties, dates, and rates, and a prettier layout that doesn’t complete the task loses. Judge every new search experience by one standard: does it get a traveler to a booking faster?
A recognizable brand is your best defense: Anyone serious about booking scrolls past a cluttered AI block and clicks the company they already know. Brand recognition is the one asset no search layout change can take from you. It’s also the long game for AI-driven matching — platforms want to pair the right property with the right guest, and known, trusted brands win that pairing.
Future-proof content by matching intent, not chasing the interface: The fix for bad AI results is the same thing Google has always chased: matching search intent to content that genuinely answers it. So keep asking where your content gets pulled from and whether you’re giving Google what it needs — comprehensive answers, accurate business data, real reviews. Best practices for AI-flavored search firm up over time; content built around real traveler intent will already comply.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul run vacation rental and hospitality searches through Google’s first AI-generated search results — the beta experiment that later evolved into AI Overviews. They break down what it got wrong, who actually benefited, and how marketers should respond when the search interface changes under their feet.