Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
A bad property can’t be saved by good marketing: The property sits at the bottom of the triangle for a reason: take on a dog and no amount of promotion digs you out. The wildly successful Instagram properties put most of their points into the unit itself — a visually unforgettable home gets extra lift on every channel because it has something nobody else has. Get that right and everything downstream gets easier.
Airbnb isn’t free — the guest is funding your acquisition cost: Between the service fee and card fees, roughly 15 to 20 percent of a booking goes to the OTA; you just don’t feel it because the guest pays most of it. Run the math on a thousand reservations at $165 in fees each — that’s $165,000 a year, and you’re crazy if you think you couldn’t build a marketing plan around that. Nobody’s saying quit the OTAs — peel off a portion and build channels you own.
Depending on one channel leaves you one lever — lowering price: When Airbnb tells Wall Street a soft quarter is coming, every Airbnb-dependent host reaches the same conclusion: drop the rate and hope the algorithm rewards you. That’s a powerless way to run a business — and accounts do get banned. The goal is options: more than one road to drive down when yours gets choppy or closed.
Guests are loyal to brands — even small local ones: Vacasa’s acquisition spree assumed guests would follow the inventory after the local brand died — they didn’t. A brand guests remember and return to compounds over time, which is exactly what the instant-ROI mindset Airbnb trained into hosts never captures.
Match the channel to who your guests actually are: One client gets far better results from Instagram than Facebook; another market is the exact opposite. Paul watched an Alaska fishing lodge insist on Instagram ads — a platform that skews heavily female — for anglers who are overwhelmingly male: beautiful ads, wrong room, and local fishing Facebook groups did more. Even billboards can work if half your guests drive in from Charlotte — not if they fly in from everywhere.
A few channels done with conviction beat twenty on autopilot: Syndicating your listings to twenty channels nobody visits is shouting into an empty room that you have properties available. A thousand dollars a month on one channel with specific targeting, purposeful creative, and a testing plan is a strategy. Find where people who would stay with you spend time, then go deep.
Interrogate every new channel before you fund it: New channels should be deliberate additions, not spray-and-pray. If you’re stopping something to make room, let the data prove it wasn’t delivering — then try the new thing with conviction.
- Does it reach people who would actually stay with you?
- Are you adding on top, or replacing something proven ineffective?
- What can go right — and what can go wrong?
- What does it cost in budget and in time?
- What data or proof will show you it’s working?
The strongest guest demand is the kind nobody searches for: People type Four Seasons into Google in cities where no Four Seasons exists — searching for a desire the market hasn’t met yet. Search volume is a starting point, but operators who beat the curve understand what guests want before guests can articulate it. Copy only what the data already shows working and you’re a copycat, competing with everyone reading the same dashboard.
Your fifth market is somebody else’s first priority: In Gatlinburg or Orlando you’re one of 35,000 to 50,000 units, and the local operator wakes up every day, hair on fire, trying to win that one market. Expansion can work with a real edge — like the client who only takes five-bedroom-and-up homes, up to sleeps-60, and owns that segment outright. Replicating your home-market system rarely counts as an edge.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul adapt Dan Kennedy’s classic message-market-media idea into a vacation rental marketing triangle — property, marketing channel, and guest demand — and work through the guest side: why the unit itself is the foundation, what OTAs actually cost you, and how to choose channels with conviction instead of tribalism.