Podcast: Is Your Paid Search Strategy A DUD Or A STUD?

Conrad O'Connell
Founder, BuildUp BookingsCo-host, Heads in Beds ShowAuthor, Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing
Conrad has worked in vacation rental marketing for over a decade. He writes from what BuildUp Bookings sees running SEO, paid ads, email and websites for vacation rental managers.
More from Conrad →Last updated: July 25, 2026
Heads In Beds Show — the vacation rental marketing podcast from BuildUp Bookings

Listen to the podcast episode

Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

Key Takeaways

Review your search terms religiously — that’s where the waste hides: Keywords you bid on and searches you show for are different things, and Google takes liberties with the gap: bid on Myrtle Beach condo rentals and you can pay for ’resorts,’ ’cheap,’ and ’luxury’ — selling tomatoes to banana shoppers. It’s the first report Conrad opens in any audit; even thousand-keyword negative lists turn up new junk weekly.

Segment campaigns narrowly so you control the budget dial: One campaign stuffed with every idea means Google decides where the money goes. Split cabin rentals and pet-friendly cabin rentals into separate campaigns — with a pet-friendly negative on the first so they don’t cross-match — each with its own budget, landing page, and dial to turn up or pause. Nobody over-segments; almost everyone is too broad.

Give each campaign enough budget to actually produce data: Ten ideas at a dollar a day teaches you nothing. On $1,000 a month, run two or three campaigns, accumulate real conversion data, then expand winners. One client started in 2017 at $1,000 a month and now profitably spends $10,000-plus most months. Low budget is fine; low patience isn’t.

Don’t hand a new campaign maximize conversions on day one: With zero conversion history, Google doesn’t know what it’s optimizing toward. Start new campaigns on maximize clicks to buy traffic and learn, then switch to maximize conversion value after 10 or 20 bookings accumulate over a few months. Give any bid-strategy test real time — a week or two proves nothing.

Use broad match with extreme caution: Broad match hands Google the keys to the castle — Paul has watched Myrtle Beach vacation rental keywords serve ads for plain ’Airbnb’ searches. Conrad’s default is phrase match with three to five tightly themed keywords per ad group, expanding only when data earns it. If an agency runs your account, ask why broad.

Target where your guests actually live, not who’s interested: Google’s default location setting is broader than you want. A Broken Bow client books almost entirely from a two-to-three-hour radius around Dallas-Fort Worth, so ads in California or India are pure waste. Target where 75 to 80 percent of bookings come from and expand later; bucket-list destinations like Hawaii, drawing guests from everywhere, are the rare exception.

Track revenue to the keyword — and define revenue first: Spending thousands a month, you need to know whether a keyword returns 2-to-1 or 50-to-1 — visible in Google Ads with a conversion segment. First decide what revenue means: gross rent or fees too? Cleaning carries almost no margin, an admin fee is nearly all margin, taxes pass through. What you feed Google drives every automated decision.

Audit your auto-apply settings before Google spends for you: Opt into the wrong auto-recommendations and Google adds broad match keywords and raises budgets without asking — often authorized by one innocuous ’want Google to improve your performance?’ email. Check the auto-apply toggles under Recommendations: about 20 exist, and the hosts opt into one or two. Dismiss every recommendation and your optimization score still reads 100.

Build out every relevant ad asset — thin ads are duds: Google rewards comprehensive ads: sitelinks, callouts, structured snippets, images, call and location assets. A beefy ad takes more screen space, earns a higher click-through rate, and gets served more often. Skip what doesn’t fit, but don’t ship a few bare headlines — and keep call tracking on, because people still call more than you’d guess.

Pace your budget with the month and the season: Google happily overspends a daily budget as long as the month evens out — the hosts use Optmyzr to watch pacing and shift dollars from a 5-to-1 campaign into a 20-to-1 one. Plan the year too: guest budgets up February through April, owner budgets down in peak summer, and mind Thanksgiving-to-Christmas retail click inflation. Never turn ads fully off; spend when bookings come.

What We Cover In This Episode

Conrad and Paul bring the dud-or-stud format to paid search: search term reviews, campaign segmentation, budget allocation, bid strategy testing, geographic targeting, revenue conversion tracking, auto-apply recommendations, ad assets, and pacing spend around the booking season.

Show Notes & Links

For Vacation Rental Managers Paying Too Much To The OTAs:

Stop Handing Airbnb 15.5% Of Every Booking

The OTA Escape Plan free direct booking guide for vacation rental managers

The OTA Escape Plan, 2027 Edition: 150 checks across 10 channels, each with why it matters, how to do it and how to know it’s done. Comes with a scorecard workbook and a new section on getting named by ChatGPT and Google’s AI.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Free. No sales call required.