Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Turn on Google Signals — it’s off by default: Google Signals enables cross-device tracking for signed-in Google users who have opted into ads personalization, and GA4 ships with it switched off. Flip it on under Data Settings > Data Collection. Guests plan trips from a work browser and book later from the couch on another device — this stitches that journey together at zero cost. No downside, only upside.
Change data retention from two months to 14: By default GA4 only keeps user and event data for two months, which quietly cripples year-over-year comparisons and multi-touch attribution reports. Standard aggregated reports aren’t affected, but the deeper analysis is. It’s a 30-second fix under Data Settings > Data Retention — go flip it on every property you run.
Switch reporting identity to Observed if accuracy matters more than modeled guesses: GA4’s default Blended identity backfills reports with modeled data — Google’s estimates of visits it couldn’t actually observe. On a huge site that smoothing can help; on the smaller sites most vacation rental managers run, it makes your numbers impossible to validate. Observed keeps user ID, Google Signals, and device ID but strips out anything Google guessed. Find it under the Reporting Identity tab.
Use your 300 custom events deliberately: GA4 allows up to 300 custom events and 30 conversions — plenty of headroom even for a large property manager. That’s not an invitation to fire an event for every property; that doesn’t scale. Make your measurement as simple as it can be, but no simpler: default events first, custom events only where they genuinely don’t fit.
Set attribution to cross-channel last click and check your lookback windows: Under Attribution Settings, cross-channel last click credits the last non-direct source that brought someone in — a fair picture of how people actually find you and convert. While you’re there, review the lookback windows: 30 days for acquisition events, with longer options for other conversions. Flipping between models can swing attributed conversions 30-50% from one channel to another, so know which lens you’re looking through.
Branded search soaks up credit it didn’t earn: Nobody wakes up and searches your company name out of the blue — an email, an ad, or word of mouth got them there first, and branded search just caught the last 1%. In last-click reports it looks like a hero while email looks like a dud, even when a send with tens of thousands of clicks did the real work. Keep running branded paid search to play defense against the OTAs, but read the credit accordingly.
Link Google Ads and Search Console inside GA4: Under Product Links, connect Google Ads and Search Console so the data lives in one view instead of three tabs you stitch together manually. Just don’t expect the numbers to match: Search Console counts clicks, GA4 counts sessions and users, and Google strips queries as removed for privacy — Conrad has seen a site lose roughly a quarter of its query data at the API level.
Find a replacement for every metric you lost: Bounce rate is gone — engagement rate is its inverse replacement. If a KPI you actually use to run the business doesn’t exist in GA4, don’t shrug: find the equivalent before you’re making decisions blind. And when the built-in reports don’t show data the way you want, build a custom report or push it into Looker Studio for anything client-facing.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul walk through the GA4 settings that quietly make or break your reports: Google Signals, data retention, reporting identity, attribution models, and product links. They also cover which familiar metrics disappeared with the old Analytics — and what to use instead.