Podcast: The Reasons To LOVE Email Marketing To Get More Direct Bookings!

Conrad O'Connell
Founder, BuildUp BookingsCo-host, Heads in Beds ShowAuthor, Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing
Conrad has worked in vacation rental marketing for over a decade. He writes from what BuildUp Bookings sees running SEO, paid ads, email and websites for vacation rental managers.
More from Conrad →Last updated: July 25, 2026
Heads In Beds Show — the vacation rental marketing podcast from BuildUp Bookings

Listen to the podcast episode

Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

Key Takeaways

Email is your lowest-cost channel — and it scales almost free: A newsletter takes the same effort whether it goes to 200 people or 200,000 — the incremental cost of a bigger list is nearly zero, which is why big lists feel like a cheat code: one send producing seven, ten, fifteen bookings. A small list won’t print cash on day one. Start anyway; the compounding only happens if you do.

A $50 discount pop-up beats 10% off: A plain join-our-newsletter pop-up converts around half a percent to 1%. A small fixed-dollar discount converts 2.5 to 5% — and fixed dollars outperform percentages even when the percentage is worth more. One client site at roughly 50,000 monthly visitors adds over a thousand emails a month at a 2.68% opt-in rate. Time it politely; don’t wreck the user experience to get it.

Capture emails offsite too — WiFi, guidebooks, rental agreements: Website pop-ups miss every guest who books you on Airbnb. WiFi capture through StayFi is the easiest fix, and if you don’t control the WiFi — condo buildings, for instance — digital guidebooks and rental-agreement opt-ins collect the same addresses. Don’t abandon offsite collection because one tool doesn’t fit your setup.

Send a welcome series the moment someone signs up: Signup is peak interest — they raised their hand; answer immediately. Welcome series open rates run as high as 75%, and the automation compounds: one client’s series ran untouched for two years and was still producing bookings (update yours more often — stale links). It also trains new subscribers to open your emails from day one.

Resend to non-openers — bookings out of thin air: A few days after each newsletter, resend to everyone who didn’t open — different subject line, different time of day. It takes minutes and reliably shakes loose another three to six bookings on a decent-sized list. Never reuse the subject line: the identical email twice from the same sender reads as spam.

Keep it 60-75% content, the rest promotion: Lead with one clear story like a newspaper front page — a team member, local news, a new trail — and slot the promotion second. The most-replied email Conrad’s team ever sent announced a Publix opening in the Outer Banks, not a property. The test is simple: do subscribers look forward to your email or brace for it?

Your local voice is the advantage the OTAs can’t copy: Airbnb and Vrbo send generic feature-property blasts; they don’t produce content about your market, and you can. Your subscribers are probably on several competitor lists too, so personality is the differentiator — a personal note from the owner, what’s actually happening in town. Subscribe to your competitors’ newsletters and see what you’re up against.

Judge email by engagement, not last-click bookings: Subscribers rarely book in the same session, and email quietly precedes the brand searches that analytics credits to Google or direct — Conrad’s been on Avantstay’s list for years; any eventual booking would look organic. Watch opens (25 to 35% is healthy for a newsletter, though open tracking is fuzzy — clicks are more reliable), traffic, and unsubscribes. Three bookings from one subscriber over years is top-tier.

Protect the list — a burned list is worthless: A 1.5% unsubscribe rate after one send is the list telling you to slow down. Conrad has watched companies pound 10,000-contact lists down to 5% opens and seven clicks per send — a list on paper, worthless in practice. Offer frequency choices and preference options instead of one cadence for everyone, and treat unsubscribe spikes as signal.

What We Cover In This Episode

Conrad and Paul make the case for email as a core direct-booking channel: building the list on-site and off, welcome series and resend plays, the content-to-promotion ratio, and reading email analytics without fooling yourself.

Show Notes & Links

For Vacation Rental Managers Paying Too Much To The OTAs:

Stop Handing Airbnb 15.5% Of Every Booking

The OTA Escape Plan free direct booking guide for vacation rental managers

The OTA Escape Plan, 2027 Edition: 150 checks across 10 channels, each with why it matters, how to do it and how to know it’s done. Comes with a scorecard workbook and a new section on getting named by ChatGPT and Google’s AI.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Free. No sales call required.