Podcast: The Success Framework: How To KNOW A Vacation Rental Will Work Well

Conrad O'Connell
Founder, BuildUp BookingsCo-host, Heads in Beds ShowAuthor, Mastering Vacation Rental Marketing
Conrad has worked in vacation rental marketing for over a decade. He writes from what BuildUp Bookings sees running SEO, paid ads, email and websites for vacation rental managers.
More from Conrad →Last updated: July 25, 2026
Heads In Beds Show — the vacation rental marketing podcast from BuildUp Bookings

Listen to the podcast episode

Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

Key Takeaways

Marketing can’t fix a property nobody wants: The panicked summer leads all sound the same: occupancy is down, revenue is down, get me bookings now. Some tactics will squeeze out a few more reservations, but the real question comes first — are you marketing something people actually desire? The 2021-22 fever pitch let almost anything book; when that demand faded, properties without real desirability fell through the floor, and no amount of clicks brings them back.

Plot every property on two axes before you spend a dollar promoting it: The x-axis is how differentiated the property is, commodity to specialty. The y-axis is how many people actually want that uniqueness. Where a property lands tells you whether it’s a marketing problem or a product problem.

  • Premium zone: highly unique with broad appeal — the target
  • Commodity zone: low uniqueness, broad appeal — viable if you admit it
  • Context-dependent zone: highly unique, narrow appeal — risky
  • Avoid zone: low uniqueness, narrow appeal — properties die here

The premium zone is unique AND broadly wanted — and that’s rare: Think oceanfront, ten bedrooms, interesting architecture, empty lots on both sides that can’t be built on. Lots of people want that thing, and almost nobody has it — a Ferrari, not a Honda. If that combination sounds hard to find, that’s exactly the point: scarcity is what makes the zone premium.

Commodity is fine — the trap is pretending you’re not one: Most managed properties are commodities: the three-bedroom beachfront condo with ten equivalents next door. That’s the Honda Accord, and Honda sells far more cars than Ferrari — broad appeal at the right price works. You get in trouble when you price and market a commodity like a premium property. Even a two-million-dollar beach house is a commodity when 34 identical ones sit beside it — uniqueness only counts in your own market.

Unique but narrow is a gamble, not a strategy: The best Vikings-themed house in the middle of Texas is genuinely unique — and nobody’s vacationing there to see it. Hobbit houses and potato houses look like genius when they land, but there’s a graveyard of unique-stay properties that never found enough people who wanted the thing. Before you build weird, ask how many travelers actually want this and whether they’ll travel to where it sits.

Match the property to what your guest actually prioritizes: Paul’s family booked a smaller, dated house in Cape Coral because the dock and boat access were perfect for a fishing trip — the person holding the credit card bought the trip’s purpose, not the prettiest interior. Families booking reunions need the whole group to eat, play, and stay together; Instagram travelers need the photo; ski guests need the access. Know which trade-offs your guest forgives and which ones sink the booking.

Run the occupancy math before you fall in love: The sustainability test: can this property hit roughly 65% occupancy at a profitable nightly rate in this market? A property people adore at 30% occupancy is interesting but unsustainable unless the premium is extreme. Unique means nothing if the market isn’t deep enough to fill the calendar.

Do the competitive homework most owners skip: Run a real SWOT on your local competition and name your actual differentiation instead of hoping travelers figure it out for you. Most owners assume the traveler will do that assessment for them — that’s not a plan. It’s the least fun part of the work, which is exactly why doing it is an edge.

Ask your five-star guests why they booked you: Everyone obsesses over bad reviews and closes the book on good ones. Add a question to your post-stay survey: why did you choose us over the alternatives? The answer is your real differentiator, and it’s often not what you think — then you can build your messaging around the thing that’s actually winning bookings.

What We Cover In This Episode

Conrad and Paul lay out a four-quadrant framework for knowing whether a vacation rental will actually work: how unique the property is, how many people want that uniqueness, and the occupancy math and competitive homework that separate premium properties from commodity traps.

Show Notes & Links

For Vacation Rental Managers Paying Too Much To The OTAs:

Stop Handing Airbnb 15.5% Of Every Booking

The OTA Escape Plan free direct booking guide for vacation rental managers

The OTA Escape Plan, 2027 Edition: 150 checks across 10 channels, each with why it matters, how to do it and how to know it’s done. Comes with a scorecard workbook and a new section on getting named by ChatGPT and Google’s AI.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Free. No sales call required.