Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
An impression just means you loaded somewhere in the results: Search Console counts an impression any time your site loads for a query — nobody had to see you, which is how one client briefly ranked for a famous landmark sharing their name and logged millions of meaningless impressions. Impressions climb before clicks when SEO starts working: you’re showing up, just at the bottom of page one. Sort by impressions descending to confirm they’re keywords you want, and read average position over four or five days — a 90-day average of 45 can hide a first-page ranking.
Read clicks at the page level, not keyword by keyword: Clients fixate on ’Destin FL vacation rentals’ while more people search without the FL. Click into a page in Search Console and you see every query it ranks for — brand terms, market terms, and gaps like a sub-area that deserves its own page because the wrong one ranks for it now. And check that clicks map to travel intent: one client ranked well for cabin-siding articles, which books nobody.
Don’t obsess over page speed scores — even Amazon barely passes: Conrad ran Amazon through PageSpeed Insights on the episode: 43 out of 100 on mobile with nearly 11 seconds of JavaScript execution — and that’s the most performant site on earth. Get loading under three seconds and you’ve captured most of the win; past that is diminishing returns. Bounce rate is the real-world alarm: if people aren’t bailing, stop tinkering.
Treat Discover as a health signal, not a traffic channel: Discover rarely sends booking-ready visitors, and it’s almost always blog content that shows there — never property pages. But sites appearing in Discover tend to do better in regular organic search, and dropping out often precedes a broader slide. Read the tab as Google’s opinion of your site.
Keep your sitemap complete — Google reports better on pages it knows: A sitemap gets new content indexed faster and unlocks better Search Console reporting. One of the largest PMS website providers in the industry leaves property pages out of sitemaps, and those listings consistently struggle to get indexed. As the site grows, split it into categorized sitemaps — properties, blog, core pages — so crawl budget flows in a straight line.
Five solid blog posts beat perfect schema on 50 listings: Enhancements and vacation rental markup are tiebreakers: if you can turn them on cheaply, do it — there’s no downside. But if you’re not producing content and building links yet, markup is a step-15 problem while you’re on step two. Even Google’s vacation rentals product only drives one or two percent of bookings for companies that integrated it.
Link Search Console, GA4, and Google Ads together: A click in Search Console is not a session in GA4 — they measure different things on purpose, and slow pages lose sessions to tracking delays. Connect every Google product anyway; the insights get stronger with a fuller picture. Ad blockers and tracking gaps are constants — keep PMS revenue data intact and treat analytics as directional.
Watch your backlinks like inventory — including the ones that vanish: Google won’t tell you when a link disappears — a client’s link on a local tubing site vanished in a redesign, and only Ahrefs caught it. Track your top 20 or 30 links, and watch for organic pickups like the local food hall that linked a client unprompted. Competitor domains in Ahrefs or Semrush are the fastest source of new page ideas.
Stop perfecting SEO; get more people searching your brand name: Across 200-plus sites Conrad has reviewed, search is almost always the top entry point for direct bookings — and much of it is branded. ’Master SEO’ has no finish line; ’get more people searching for my company’ is a question every channel you run can help answer. It’s the most useful reframe in the episode.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul reset the vocabulary of organic search: what impressions, clicks, average position, Core Web Vitals, Discover, sitemaps, and schema enhancements actually mean in Search Console and GA4 — and which numbers should change what you do next. They close with how they use Ahrefs and Semrush to track links and mine competitor sites for ideas.