Listen to the podcast episode
Or listen now on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Key Takeaways
Read the comments — don’t just count them: Engagement is likes, comments, and shares, but the number is buyable and the nuance isn’t. The comments that matter come from real potential guests: are these dates available, what’s your pet policy, where exactly is this. Conrad would take 100-200 people who actually care over 1,000 purchased followers — he’s seen a million-like page get less reach than a 200K page that actually posts.
Reach means nothing if it’s the same 400 people on repeat: Impressions count views; reach counts humans. 15,000 impressions hitting the same small audience means frequency is climbing, and when people see the same ad 10, 15, 20 times, performance decays. With the small audiences most vacation rental brands run, watch frequency and refresh creative before you burn the list out.
Install the Meta pixel this week: Paul’s PSA to start 2025: if the pixel isn’t on your website, you can’t build audiences of the people who already visited — which is exactly who you want to stay in front of while they’re in the inspiration phase of planning a trip. It costs nothing, and everything downstream in paid social depends on it.
Start paid social with retargeting at $5-10 a day: Before touching cold audiences, run ads to your website visitors, your email list, and your existing followers. Conrad’s line: if you can’t justify $5 a day to stay in front of people who already know you, you can’t justify any advertising. Don’t expect same-session bookings — this is how you stay remembered until the brand search happens later.
Batch-shoot video once, feed the channel for months: Video dominates social performance now, and the client doesn’t have a video is no longer an acceptable shrug — get one shot. One client blocked a slow December day, filmed eight or nine homes, and handed over months of material to chop into posts and ads. Keep statics and carousels running alongside to mop up the ad inventory video doesn’t reach.
Use dynamic creative as your budget-friendly test lab, with eyes open: Paul feeds Meta multiple headlines and images — earn more, ROI, peace of mind — and lets delivery reveal what an owner market actually responds to. Know the trade: Meta picks winners early, never tells you why, and a true A/B test needs its own testing ad set, which only makes sense at bigger budgets. At small spend, run what you have, read the data, kill what fails.
Stop expecting clicks — measure social on ROAS over quarters: A link post kills organic reach, and even on paid, clearing a 1% click-through rate means you’re doing well. People rarely click from Instagram and book in the same session; they come back later through brand search. So judge Meta ads on ROAS over a quarter, not a week — and always against the question of whether that dollar would do better in Google.
Facebook and Instagram first, TikTok third, Pinterest basically never: Meta’s billion-plus users are where vacation rental reach and intent live — master that before anything else. TikTok is lumpy even for big accounts: one hit, then goose egg after goose egg. And Pinterest sends volume without intent — Conrad watched 50-60,000 annual visitors from it show no signs of life, like cabin-builders in Oregon browsing Tennessee cabin interiors with zero plans to travel.
If the property isn’t the show, social isn’t your channel: Visually striking inventory performs on social because the property itself is the content. Standard inventory struggles on both organic and paid, and some clients skip social ads entirely because search simply converts better for them. Match the channel to the inventory, not to the trend.
What We Cover In This Episode
Conrad and Paul decode the social media terms you’ll hear from anyone running your accounts — engagement, reach, impressions, frequency, retargeting, creatives, CTR, ROAS — through the actual decisions each one drives, plus where Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest, and YouTube rank for vacation rental brands.